Interactive Comparison Tool

Compare Pool Types Side-by-Side

Make an informed decision with our comprehensive pool comparison. See exactly how Concrete, Fiberglass, and Liner pools stack up on price, maintenance, longevity, and total cost of ownership.

Concrete
$80K - $130K
Fiberglass
$60K - $100K
Vinyl Liner
$50K - $80K

Select 2 or more pool types to compare

How They Stack Up

Every detail matters when choosing your pool. Here's how each type compares across key factors.

Category Concrete Fiberglass Vinyl Liner

What's Included?

See which features come standard or are available with each pool type.

Concrete Fiberglass Liner

20-Year Cost of Ownership

Initial price is just the beginning. See the true cost over two decades including maintenance and replacements.

Concrete Pool
Fiberglass Pool
Vinyl Liner Pool

Concrete Total

$145K
$105K initial + $40K maintenance

Fiberglass Total

$100K
$80K initial + $20K maintenance

Vinyl Liner Total

$105K
$65K initial + $30K maint + $10K liner

Pros and Cons

We believe in transparency. Here's the good and the not-so-good for each pool type.

Concrete Pool

Pros

  • Unlimited customization - any shape, size, or depth
  • Longest lifespan (50+ years with proper care)
  • Highest resale value impact
  • Integrated spa options available
  • Premium aesthetic with custom finishes
  • Can be renovated/resurfaced over time

Cons

  • Highest upfront cost
  • Longest installation time (8-12 weeks)
  • Rougher surface texture
  • Most prone to algae growth
  • Higher annual maintenance costs
  • Requires acid washing every 3-5 years

Fiberglass Pool

Pros

  • Fastest installation (2-4 weeks)
  • Lowest maintenance of all types
  • Smooth, non-porous surface
  • Best algae resistance
  • Lower lifetime cost
  • Excellent warranty coverage (15-25 years)

Cons

  • Limited to pre-made shapes and sizes
  • Cannot add integrated spa after install
  • Width limited by transportation
  • Surface can fade over decades
  • Repairs more complex if shell cracks

Vinyl Liner Pool

Pros

  • Lowest initial investment
  • Smooth, comfortable surface
  • Many pattern and color options
  • Non-abrasive on skin and swimwear
  • Quick installation (3-5 weeks)
  • Flexible sizing options

Cons

  • Liner replacement every 7-10 years ($4-6K)
  • Vulnerable to punctures and tears
  • Shorter overall lifespan (15-20 years)
  • Lower resale value impact
  • Seams can separate over time
  • Fading from sun and chemicals

Which Pool Is Right for You?

Based on your priorities, here's our honest recommendation.

For Most Main Line Families: Fiberglass

We recommend fiberglass pools because they offer the best balance of quality, value, and convenience. You'll spend your weekends enjoying your pool, not maintaining it.

  • Fastest installation - swimming in weeks
  • Lowest total cost of ownership
  • Virtually maintenance-free surface
  • Excellent 15-25 year warranties

Choose Concrete If...

You want a truly custom pool experience and are willing to invest in the premium option for maximum flexibility and longevity.

  • Custom shape is essential to your design
  • You want an integrated spa
  • Building a luxury estate feature
  • 50+ year lifespan matters to you
  • You have flexibility on timeline

Consider Vinyl Liner If...

You're working with a tighter budget but still want a quality in-ground pool experience for your family.

  • Budget is your primary concern
  • You're comfortable with liner replacement
  • Planning to move in 10-15 years
  • Want the most pool for the money now

Still Deciding?

We're here to help you make the right choice for your family and property.